The Lasting Impact of Bell — interactive website about Deaf education history

The Lasting Impact of Bell

Alexander Graham Bell, Oralism, and the Deaf Community

This project explores the lasting impact of Alexander Graham Bell on Deaf education. While he is widely known for inventing the telephone, his beliefs about deaf people shaped how deaf children were taught for generations.

Through history, interviews, and interactive experiences, this project examines how the push for speech over sign language led to language deprivation and continues to influence the Deaf community today.

This is not just history. This is still happening.

"This site was created to educate, spark conversation, and honor the Deaf community."

Developed by Tanner Ketchum

Rochester Institute of Technology  ·  Media Narrative  ·  Final Project  ·  2026

Stories and Perspectives

This section features interviews with faculty from NTID who share their knowledge on Deaf history, education, and language access. Their perspectives help connect past events to present experiences.

This video has no audio — please turn on captions (CC) to follow along.

If the video does not load, watch it directly on YouTube ↗

Download Transcript

Ben Jarashow

Ben Jarashow

Senior Lecturer, NTID
"Many Deaf people were never taught their own language, culture, and history."

Ben Jarashow serves as a Senior Lecturer for the Deaf Culture Studies program at the National Technical Institute for the Deaf. His work centers on amplifying Deaf history and cultural identity — subjects that have long been withheld from the very communities they belong to.

Deirdre Schlehofer

Deirdre Schlehofer

Associate Professor, NTID
"We must remember that every language is natural and should not be modified or manipulated."

Dr. Schlehofer coordinates the Deaf Culture Studies program in the Department of Liberal Studies at NTID, where she also serves as an Associate Professor. Her scholarship spans sociolinguistics and Deaf culture, and she currently teaches courses including Deaf Women Studies — bringing underrepresented perspectives to the forefront of academic study.

Denise Kavin

Denise Kavin

Faculty, Department of Liberal Studies
"The role of sign language — it is the anchor, and it is everything. To me, it is the core, and everything is around sign. Really, that is the heart of Deaf identity."

Denise Kavin is a faculty member in the Department of Liberal Studies at NTID, where she coordinates the BS program in Community Development and Inclusive Leadership. Her work focuses on building inclusive communities that honor Deaf identity, language access, and the transformative power of sign language.

History That Still Shapes Today

Click each event to expand.

March 3, 1847
Alexander Graham Bell Born
Bell family historical photo
Bell family — historical photo
Born in Edinburgh, Scotland into a family focused on speech and communication. His mother was deaf, influencing his early interest in sound and teaching speech to the deaf.
1870
Bell Moves to the United States
Alexander Graham Bell with his family and friends
Alexander Graham Bell with his family and friends (Library of Congress)
Bell moves to the U.S. and begins teaching deaf students. He focuses on speech and lip reading instead of sign language, establishing a philosophy that would define his life's work: that deaf people should be taught to speak and assimilate into hearing society.
March 7, 1876
Bell Patents the Telephone
Bell telephone patent historical photo
Bell patents the telephone — March 7, 1876
Bell patents the telephone. His success gives him enormous influence, allowing him to promote his views on deaf education far more widely and fund his oralist advocacy for decades.
July 11, 1877
Bell Marries Mabel Hubbard
Bell and his wife Mabel
Bell with his wife Mabel Hubbard
Bell marries Mabel Gardiner Hubbard, who was deaf. They later have four children. Despite this, he continues to advocate for speech over sign language and opposes Deaf people forming communities.
September 1880
Milan Conference Bans Sign Language
Newspaper headline — Milan Conference, 1880
Newspaper headline — Milan Conference, 1880
Educators vote to ban sign language in schools. Oral education becomes dominant and deaf teachers lose their roles. Bell was a strong advocate for this movement. This decision shapes Deaf education for nearly 100 years.
1883
Bell Expands His Ideology
Alexander Graham Bell, c. 1883
Alexander Graham Bell, c. 1883
Bell publishes ideas warning against deaf people marrying each other and forming communities — rooted in eugenicist thinking about preventing "a deaf variety of the human race."
1890
AG Bell Association Founded
Bell and Mabel at telephone landmark plaque, 1916
Bell and Mabel at telephone landmark plaque, 1916
The Alexander Graham Bell Association for the Deaf and Hard of Hearing is established to promote speech and listening education. It continues to support oral methods and influence deaf education policy to this day.
1880s–1900s
Sign Language Removed from Schools
Oral speech lesson, New York School for the Deaf
Oral speech lesson, New York School for the Deaf
Following the Milan Conference, many schools remove sign language. Deaf students are forced to rely on speech alone, limiting full language development. Deaf teachers are almost entirely pushed out of the profession.
Early 1900s
Impact on Deaf Students
Speech training — Gallaudet University Archives
Speech training — Gallaudet University Archives
Many deaf students struggle with learning and communication. Without access to sign language, language development is significantly delayed. Deaf teachers are almost entirely pushed out of schools, reducing representation in education.
1960
William Stokoe Proves ASL Is a Real Language
William Stokoe, linguist who proved ASL is a real language
William Stokoe, linguist who proved ASL is a real language
Linguist William Stokoe publishes research proving that American Sign Language is a complete, fully structured language with its own grammar and syntax. This begins to change attitudes toward Deaf education worldwide.
Late 1900s
Sign Language Returns to Schools
Deaf students reacting to Gallaudet protest, late 1980s
Deaf students reacting to Gallaudet protest, late 1980s
Schools begin reintroducing sign language. Deaf culture gains recognition, and bilingual education starts to grow. The Deaf community begins reclaiming its identity and language after nearly a century of suppression.
Today
The Debate Continues
Deaf child with cochlear implant in bilingual classroom — today
Deaf child with cochlear implant in bilingual classroom — today
Debates about speech versus sign language continue. Some deaf children still face limited language access early in life. Language deprivation remains a documented crisis. Bell's legacy lives on through institutions and policies that continue to shape how society responds to deafness.
"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it. The history of Deaf education is not just a record of what was done — it is a warning about what must never be done again."

Experience Language Restriction

This activity gives you a glimpse into what deaf students experienced during the oralism era. The goal is not to replicate deafness, but to help you feel the frustration caused by restricted communication.

Activity Steps

1

Make sure captions (CC) are enabled on YouTube before starting the video.

2

Watch the first part of the video — it has no audio and no captions. Experience it as it is.

3

Pause the video before the second part begins. Write down what you understood from what you watched.

4

Continue to the second part — captions and audio are now enabled. Watch it fully.

5

Reflect on the difference between the two parts.

If the video does not load, watch it directly on YouTube ↗

Reflection Questions

How did it feel to not fully understand what was happening?

What changed when access was provided?

How might this feel if it happened every day, in every class, for your entire education?

Ignorance

Sometimes ignorance doesn't look like cruelty — it looks like celebration. The example below shows how a major institution can honor Bell's legacy while remaining unaware of, or indifferent to, the harm that legacy caused the Deaf community — and the irony that follows.

AT&T 150 years of the telephone

AT&T celebrates 150 years of the telephone — and donates to the Bell Legacy Foundation

In March 2026, AT&T marked the 150th anniversary of Alexander Graham Bell's first telephone call by proudly tracing its origins back to Bell Telephone Company. The company donated $150,000 to the Alexander and Mabel Bell Legacy Foundation, describing Bell as a "founding innovator" whose genius "changed the world."

What the celebration leaves out: Bell was also a leading advocate for oralism — the movement to ban sign language from Deaf education — and held eugenicist views about Deaf people. Honoring Bell's legacy without acknowledging this history erases the suffering of generations of Deaf children who were denied access to their natural language.

Source: AT&T — 150 Years of the First Telephone Call (2026)
Gallaudet and AT&T 5G helmets

The Irony: AT&T also supports Gallaudet's football program

At the same time, AT&T is a proud sponsor of the Gallaudet University Bison football team. They developed the AT&T 5G Helmet — the first helmet designed for Deaf and hard of hearing players — using augmented reality and 5G technology to help coaches communicate with players on the field in real time.

The helmet was approved for NCAA play in 2024. Gallaudet even invented the huddle in 1894 as a way to communicate without opponents reading their signs.

So AT&T donates money to an organization honoring the man who fought to silence Deaf people — while also funding technology that helps Deaf athletes compete. The contradiction is right there, side by side.

Source: AT&T 5G Helmet — Gallaudet University

What this tells us

This is not necessarily malicious. It is a perfect example of how Bell's harm has been normalized — so thoroughly absorbed into the culture that a corporation can simultaneously fund his memorial and support the very community he tried to suppress, without seeing any contradiction at all.

That is what institutionalized ignorance looks like. Not hatred. Just a complete absence of awareness about whose story is being told, and whose is being left out.

Take Action

Learning about history is important, but what we do next matters even more. Here are simple ways you can support language access and the Deaf community.

1. Support Early Language Access

Deaf children need full access to language from the beginning.

Support the use of sign language alongside other communication methods.

2. Challenge Misconceptions

Many people still believe outdated ideas about deafness and communication.

Speak up when you hear things like "sign language is not necessary" or "deaf people should just speak."

3. Learn Basic Sign Language

Learning even a few signs can improve communication and show respect for Deaf culture.

It also helps create a more inclusive environment.

4. Listen to Deaf Perspectives

Deaf people are the experts of their own experiences.

Follow Deaf creators, learn from their stories, and center their perspectives.

5. Support Inclusive Education

Encourage schools and programs to support bilingual education — sign language and written or spoken language.

Access to language should never be limited.

Awareness is the first step. Action creates change.

Learn More and Get Involved

These organizations support Deaf education, language access, and the Deaf community. You can explore their work and learn more.

NAD logo

National Association of the Deaf

NAD

Advocates for the rights of Deaf and hard of hearing individuals, including language access and education.

nad.org
LEAD-K logo

LEAD-K

LEAD-K

Focuses on ensuring deaf children have full access to language from an early age.

lead-k.org
Gallaudet University logo

Gallaudet University

Washington, D.C.

A leading university for Deaf and hard of hearing students, promoting Deaf culture and education.

gallaudet.edu
RIT NTID logo

National Technical Institute for the Deaf

NTID at RIT

Provides education and resources for Deaf and hard of hearing students at RIT.

rit.edu/ntid
Communication Service for the Deaf logo

Communication Service for the Deaf

CSD

A Deaf-led organization providing interpreting services, technology solutions, and social ventures that advance the Deaf community.

csd.org
American Society for Deaf Children logo

American Society for Deaf Children

ASDC

Supports and empowers families raising deaf and hard of hearing children by promoting full language access and Deaf identity.

deafchildren.org

These are just a few organizations. There are many others working to support the Deaf community and promote language access.

Teaching Resources

Downloadable materials for educators organized by grade level.

Elementary

  • Introduction to Sign Language Download
  • What Is Deafness? Discussion Guide Download

Middle School

  • Deaf History Timeline Activity Download
  • Language Access Discussion Questions Download
  • Alexander Graham Bell: Two Sides Lesson Plan Download

High School

  • Milan 1880 — What Really Happened Download
  • Oralism vs. Bilingualism Debate Activity Download
  • Language Deprivation Research Guide Download

College / University

  • Eugenics and the Deaf Community — Academic Reading Download
  • Critical Analysis: Bell's Legacy Lesson Plan Download
  • Intersectionality and Deaf Identity Discussion Guide Download

References and Acknowledgments

This project is supported by historical research, academic sources, and contributions from NTID faculty.

Image Sources

Thank you to the faculty and researchers at NTID who shared their knowledge, time, and perspectives.

As a Deaf individual, this topic is deeply personal to me. This project is my way of sharing that history with others — so it is never forgotten.